Hoover And Roosevelt Had Very Different Ideas On How The

This essay Hoover And Roosevelt Had Very Different Ideas On How The has a total of 938 words and 5 pages.

Hoover and Roosevelt had very different ideas on how the

Depression should be handled. This was almost entirely a result of two
integral differences in their schemas; Hoover was a Republican, and
had basically worked his way through life, while Roosevelt was not
only a Democrat, he had basically been born with the proverbial silver
spoon in his mouth. As one can easily see, in many ways these two are
complete opposites; in fact, if one looks at both their upbringing and
their political affiliation, it seems that Roosevelt's and Hoover's
policies must have been different in a great many ways. Hoover was
brought up in a poor family, and worked almost his entire life. When
he was eight years old, his parents died so he went to live with his
uncle. His uncle worked with him, and later became rich. Hoover had
endured a great many hardships in his life, and knew what it was like
to do without. In fact, Hoover was very poor as a child, although not
necessarily living in poverty. This effect on his schema would be
rather interesting, as it seems that he should have had a better
understanding of how to handle problems with the poor than Roosevelt.

As Hoover was born poor, one would think that he would know how to run
the country like a business, so that it would stay afloat; however,
when confronted with the Depression, he repeatedly cut taxes. Hoover
was basically a hard working Republican, the quintessential self made
man. Roosevelt, on the other hand, had been born into a very rich
family; He grew up with education at Harvard, had his own pony and
sailboat, and had everything basically taken care of for him in his
childhood by his mother. This gave him a sense of security, of being
able to do anything he wanted, most simply because he didn't fail
early on. He had never lived through what the American public was
going through, so his view of the world, his schema, did not
necessarily include what it was like to live in poverty. He believed
that the Depression could be solved merely by putting as many people
to work for the government as possible. This could relate to how,
growing up, he himself did not have to work in any way, shape, or
form. Roosevelt did have one other perspective that would always be
unavailable to Hoover; he was a cripple. He had contracted polio on

1921; by the time he became governor of New York in 1928, he could not
walk unaided. He refused to let this stop him, though, and remained a
suave speaker, unlike his competitor Hoover.

Political affiliation is also one of the most necessary
differences to realize in contrasting Hoover and Roosevelt. Hoover's
policies, when viewed form the modern perspective, seem rather
strange. One of his major efforts appears to have been lowering taxes;
he basically expressed faith in the existent American system. He
called leaders of industry to Washington D.C. and made them promise to
keep up wages and such, but when they did not he worked with local
welfare agencies. He basically refused to give out any national
welfare, believing that it demeaned proud Americans. While he
attempted much to help businesses, it was clear by 1932 that his
policies were a complete failure. Even when the Democrats had control
of the congress after 1930, he still stubbornly refused to take
stronger action. Throughout this time, the bank failures had been
steadily going up. His lowest point in popularity was when a group of
veterans camped in D.C. demanding a bonus that they were due. Hoover
ordered them removed. Yet even through all of this, he still insisted
that the American public did not honestly want national relief.

Basically, Roosevelt could have no better campaign than Hoover's
presidency. Roosevelt's philosophy, on the other hand, was entirely
different. His most readily apparent ability was his voice; he was
able to talk to people in such a way that they almost always went
along with him. He was exceptionally confident, and made those around
him feel so too. Roosevelt did not tend to deal with underlying
problems; he was, however, wonderful at taking care of the surface
problem. On his inauguration day, he gave his famous speech asserting
that the only thing America had to fear was fear itself; not entirely
true, because the nation stood on the brink of collapse. The banks in

Chicago and New York were closed. Within ten days, Roosevelt had them
back open. Throughout the next few years, Roosevelt's general policy
was to make work for anyone and everyone who

Read essay without registering

Donate an essay now and get the full essay emailed you




Acceptable files: .txt, .doc, .docx, .rtf

Email Address

Topics Related to Hoover And Roosevelt Had Very Different Ideas On How The

Freemen of the City of London, Sons of the American Revolution, United States Assistant Secretaries of the Navy, Schuyler family, Herbert Hoover, Theodore Roosevelt, The Hoover Company, Great Depression, Criticism of Franklin D. Roosevelt

Essays Related to Hoover And Roosevelt Had Very Different Ideas On How The