A Comparison between the Works of Amedeo Modigliani and Jacques Villon


Comparison between the Works of Amedeo Modigliani and Jacques Villon

Italian-born Cubist painter, Amedeo

Modigliani (1884-1920) and the French, Jacques Villon (1875-1963), both
painted vibrant and expressive portraits during the early twentieth-century.

In this case, the chosen portraits are Modigliani\'s "Portrait of Mrs. Hastings",

1915 and Villon\'s "Mme. Fulgence", 1936.

Both of these compositions are portraits.

Nothing is of more importance than the sitter herself. The female sitter
in Modigliani\'s piece, sits in an almost dizzying pose with a twist in
her elongated neck (a Modigliani trademark), a stylized and mask-like head
and a columnar neck. All of which give the sitter a blank and
ashen expression. She looks at the viewer, head-on with a most piercing
air in her eyes. In Villon\'s case, his female sitter has been created
solely with the use of layered colours and a very random synthetist outline
technique (a similar technique the post-impressionist painter Gaugin used).

Modigliani outlines his figure moreso in black than Villon.

Mme. Fulgence\'s age is understood by the strong dynamic colour quality
that has been used to break her face apart. In a way, these colourful
divisions act as wrinkles. For instance, the chunk of layered pink
on her lip creates a scowl and the heavily applied white on her nose helps
it to seem upright; a \'snobbish\' upturn. Colours such as the orange,
have been used to highlight her left cheek and only visible ear.

With these effects, the viewer sees Mme. Fulgence as a very proper and\'posh\' (if you will) woman. Bitterness is only a common linkage with
the other attributes. Modigliani\'s Hastings on the other hand seems
to be an intense woman of a compassionate nature. Both of these pieces
have relied heavily on the expressive and wild use of colour to create
emotional expressions and unerring form.

Both of these portraits are created
using oil paints--Modigliani\'s on cardboard and Villon\'s on canvas.

The most important element that draws their work away from the mainstream
is their heavy application of paint. Although they both apply their
colour liberally, Modigliani\'s strokes are thick, jagged, and for the most
part random. His brushstrokes are also particularly long, whereas

Villon\'s are short and brief. Modigliani uses monochromatic hues
of red to create the prominent colour of the piece and like Villon, he
has used a very vague background to express the importance of his sitter.

Colour is of equal importance in both pieces as it draws the viewer in
and allows the viewer\'s eyes to be brought around the piece. Modigliani
has split his background from top to bottom, using red and strokes of burnt
sienna at first, then an auburn and deeper red for the bottom. This
definite split in the background creates a base so that the chair on which
the sitter is seated does not get lost and mistaken for part of the background.

The weighty application in both portraits
creates a brilliant textural finish. The expressive nature that is
brought out in the quick brushstrokes is equally defined in the actual
texture of the painting plain. In Modigliani\'s background, the strokes
are long and applied at a rapid pace. Whereas in Villon\'s background,
his strokes are shorter and seem to have more of a planned location (just
as Seurat applies his paint).

Villon has placed his subject in
front of the background in an almost symmetrical manner. This poses
the idea that the two really do not have an intense relationship whatsoever.

The \'Madame\' is not quite centred to look at the viewer dead-on as Modigliani\'s
is, her body is shifted slightly to the left. Modigliani\'s sitter,
on the other hand has been placed carefully on her foreground, off to the
left. This brings in ample space for the chair. Having his
subject seated, Modigliani says more about the subject\'s surroundings.

Villon has merely placed Mme. Fulgence in front of a green background,
with only the highlights of her age to carry one through the piece.

As stated before, the negative space that is prevalent in both pieces is
highly effective as it does not take away from the issue at hand: the seated.

Both artists have used the application
of their colours to their advantage in creating emotion merely through
its use. Whether the colours are blended like Modigliani or choppy
and difficult to ingest (for the colours are used at their most vibrant
tone) as Villon\'s are, both artist\'s used an extreme colour palette to
bring forth the ideal emotions and/or physical standing of their models.