EXTENDED ESSAY (5602 words)

5602 WORDS
Read the full essay 5602 words

Asian Philosophies of Critical Thinking: divergent or convergent to western establishments?

By Clement Ng

SCHOOL CODE: 1206 (Sha Tin College)

CANDIDATE CODE: MAY 2003 - 1206 038


The research question of this extended essay came across at a very early stage in my life. Having been born and developed from a family with all its members being University instructors and professors, I was often involved in arguments related to the lack of critical thinking in Asian cultures. As I got older, having had the chance to emerge in different cultures, I started to develop my own viewpoints and answers. I started to wonder about the truth between the real differences of Asian and Western philosophies of critical thinking. This extended essay, intended to be a research and investigation, bearing the title "Asian Philosophies of Critical Thinking: divergent or convergent to Western establishments?" is in fact however merely just a summary of my viewpoints and answers which I have developed throughout the years.

In the first section of the essay, "Logical Tradition in India and China" I will attempt to give evidence of critical thinking in two Asian cultures that I have chosen; namely India and China. In India, I will argue that critical thinking is clearly visible in historical texts such as the Caraka and Nyayasutra. This is presented as the well-known five-membered argument, a system of logical deduction, similar to the Aristotelian syllogism found in the west. In China I would focus mainly on the two schools of logical thought, the Mohists and the Logicians. For the Mohists I would argue that critical thinking is a vital element in the building of what they call "mental models." For the Logicians, I would study deeply the writings of Hui Shih and Kungsun Lung, I would show that in fact both of them developed systems of logical and paradoxical thinking that could well serve as the foundations of modern science.

If critical thinking is clearly presentable in these Asian cultures then why are there still concerns for introducing it to them? This is the question I intend to answer in the latter section "Needham's Grand Question and Fuller's Interpretation." During this section, I would also show that discussions of modern science seem to enable us to see how the tradition of critical thinking arose and how they were promoted or discouraged. I would cover how Asian historical, economic, social and cultural factors have a big influence on their development of critical thinking. Lastly I would show how the prioritization of a civilization has a devastating effect on deciding the future road they intend to walk.

In conclusion, I would argue that since the philosophy of a culture is but an abstract and theoretical expression and justification of the culture's decision to choose one set of priorities over another, Asian philosophy and critical thinking are neither necessarily divergent nor necessarily convergent to western establishments.


Introduction 4

Logical Tradition in India and China 4

Needham's Grand Question and Fuller's Interpretation 7

Asian Philosophy and Critical Thinking: Divergence or Convergence? 8

Conclusion 9

Bibliography 10

References 11

Asian Philosophies of Critical Thinking: divergent or convergent to western establishments?

By Clement Ng


It is widely recognized nowadays that critical thinking has become a necessary ingredient in all levels of education. Educators and educational policy makers agree that one of the desirable goals of education is that students are able to think critically. Throughout the past few years, many have felt the need to consider critical thinking more seriously in educational programs. At the moment several different acts are being considered around the world by various factors and agencies. The core of these proposed acts is the idea that the students are able to think critically and independently. Although there are widespread disagreements on what critical thinking actually is,[1] there is an agreement that it has become very important in the world overwhelmed by huge amounts of information.

Some Western educators who teach at schools or universities in a number of Asian countries have voiced their difficulties and problems they encounter while trying to teach critical thinking and other related skills to Asian students. Bruce Davidson (1998) argues that a set of Japanese cultural factors act as a kind of barrier against teaching critical thinking to students. Atkinson (1999) goes so far as to

Related Topics

Philosophy Logic Education Epistemology Indian philosophy Critical thinking Philosophy of education Thought Informal logic Indian logic Argumentation theory Buddhist logico-epistemology

More Free Essays Like This

1984 by George Orwell (1903 - 1950)
A baby was born on July 12 or 13 of 100 BC in Rome
A Brief History of the Blues
A Dolls House Henrik Ibsen (1828-1906)
A Farewell to Arms by Ernest Hemingway (1899 - 196
A History of Christianity in Egypt
A man of Scotland, a distinguished citizen of the
A. Personal Information
A Post-Modern Age?
A Streetcar Named Desire
A vogadro was born on June 9, 1776 in Turin, Italy
AIDS - Whats new
Alexander The Great was one of the greatest empero
Animal Farm as Animal Satire
Anti-Semitism in Nazi Germany
Antigone: Divine Law vs. Human Law
Aristotle was born in 384 BC and lived until 322 B
Black Boy
Black Panthers
Born in 1817, in Concord, Henry David Thoreau beca
Britain and Europe in the Seventeenth Century
Building in the Voice of the Customer
By the time Hadrians contributions to his country
Call of the Wild by Jack London (1876 - 1916)
Canada has long been called The Mosaic, due to t
Candide - A Contrast to Optimism
Candide by Voltaire (1694 - 1778)
Carl Gustav Jung (1875-1961) was a son of a minist
Catcher in the Rye
Cicero, was truly a man of the state. His writings
Communism in the USSR was doomed from the onset. C
Compared to the technical theaters of today, the L
Comparison of Spartan and Samurai Warriors
Confucius was believed to have been born in 551 BC
Crime and Punishment
Cry, the Beloved Country
Death of a Salesman
Death of a Salesman by Arthur Miller (1915 - )
Death ofA Salesman
Early Egyptian Religious Beliefs and Akhenatens R
Economic Growth
English Story
Far From the Madding Crowd by Thomas Hardy (1840 -
Fascist Germany The Result of Instability
Faust by Goethe (1749 - 1832)
Frank Lloyd Wright The Pioneer of creating Greatne
Frederick James - The Limites of Post Modern Theor
Free to Choose
George Wallace
Great Depression
Greek Mythology and Religion
Had more sense. Whether his neighbors were cool or
Heart of Darkness By Joseph Conrad
Hello, Im John Quincy Adams. I grew up in Braintr
Herman Melville
History--Historical Analysis of Jerzy Kosinskis T
History of Psychology
History of Unions and Their Relevance in Todays S
Honda Marketing Strategy
Hoover and Roosevelt had very different ideas on h
In todays society, a troubled teenager or mischie
Invisible Man - Identity
Iran is a country located in the Middle East. The
It is important to realize that the treatment of w
Julius Caesar
Karl Heinrich Marx was born on May 5, 1818, in the
Karl Marx
Karl Marx
Karl Marx
Karl Marx Biography and Synopsis of Views
Legacy from the Middle ages
Lord of the Flies
Main Street by Sinclair Lewis
Martin Luther was a German theologian and religiou
Michelangelo was pessimistic in his poetry and an
Middle Ages and The Renaissance
Moby Dick, or The Whale
Most Influential Person in History- Socrates
Multiculturalism in Canada
My own philosophy of education is rather difficult
Name = Monica McKirdy
Nike is the leading shoe and athletic apparel comp
On April 1986, Soviets Union Chernobyl nuclear pl
On December 10, 1986 the Greater New York Section
On September 1, 1939, the German military forces i
Other Minds
Over the past fifteen years a powerfully charged d
Philosophy - Nozicks Entiltlement Theory