Lincoln Could He Have Preserved the Union


Could He Have Preserved the Union

From the time the South demanded the return
of Fort Sumter and Fort Pickens, tension had been building in expectation
of Lincolnís reply. The options available to Lincoln were limited,
and those that were available were further limited by constraints of time
and man-power.

Lincolnís options were also limited by
his goals. Lincoln had a set agenda, with preserving the Union at
the head of the list. Lincoln also aimed to preserve Fort Sumter
and Fort Pickens. Lincolnís most pressing goal was to instigate the
war without seeming to be the aggressor. This proved to be the most
difficult goal, because to achieve this, he had to know how far to push
without seeming to push at all. An additional goal was to perhaps
lure the border states onto the northern side. This was an important
goal because it fell in line with Lincolnís un-hostile attitude. By being
attacked first, he could say he was responding to an act of war on the

United States.

One of Lincolnís options was to sit by
and do nothing. This was not really an option, however, because abandoning
his soldiers at this fort would not only lower the morale of his entire
army, but could also turn many of his supporters against him. So, needless
to say, Lincoln could not really consider this as an option. Lincoln, for
a time, also entertained the idea of compromise. The southern resolve
was so concrete that this idea was abandoned rather quickly.

Another idea, proposed by Secretary of

State Seward, was to abandon Fort Sumter and concentrate on Fort Pickens.

Lincoln did not accept this idea either, mainly because abandoning a fort
anywhere in the South would recognize the South as an independent nation.

Even so, Seward managed to get a force together, and taking one of the
strongest ships in the United States Navy, went to Pickens anyway.

One idea with similar traits was the idea to abandon both forts, leaving
the South. Though open to consideration, this was not at all in line
with Lincolnís thinking. Again this would recognize the South as
an independent nation, which would finalize the secession.

For lack of a better idea, some suggested
the reinforcing of the forts, to protect them from bombardment. This
idea was cast aside also, because, first of all, Fort Sumter lies in between
two points of land, both protected by forts. To make this idea work,
those forts would have to be taken, too. Lincoln could not amass
the needed number of soldiers, either. Secondly, the thought of risking
more lives on just a pile of rock in the middle of a harbor was not appealing.

Considering the resolve of the Southern
states, Lincoln for a while considered a military invasion. This,
however, was not feasible. Lincolnís forces were so scattered, it
would take weeks on end to produce enough soldiers to achieve this goal.

An estimate by General in chief Scott suggested "5,000 regular troops and

20,000 volunteers." (Current 50) The time frame for collecting this number
of soldiers was much greater than the supplies in Sumter could last.

Fort Sumter was also reinforced by surrounding forts in Charleston Harbor,
meaning a loss of soldiers could be expected also.

Lincolnís most favored option, the one
he eventually went with, was to take a non-aggressive force into the harbor,
carrying supplies in to the short-rationed soldiers. Although Lincoln
went in under peaceful pretenses, one could assume that he was attempting
to achieve his goal of appearing to be the tormented, not the tormentor.

His ploy worked, and the South did as predicted and fired upon the re-supply
fleet. By achieving his non-aggressor goal, Lincoln also strengthened
his case for winning the border states.

Lincoln was faced with a dilemma when he
had to decide between peace or unity. The southern resolve eliminated
any chance of compromise, so Lincoln had to chose the route which seemed
the best for the Union. He could not be seen as aggressive, because
if he did he risked losing the support of the border states, which could
reduce the Union to nothing. To reiterate, the southern statesí hard
nose attitude encouraged no deliberation, so no compromise could have ever
been achieved. Lincoln, in light of this incident, might not
be seen as your typical image of "Honest Abe", but he comes shining through
as a great leader.