This essay Nazi Ethics Debate has a total of 1740 words and 10 pages.
Nazi Ethics Debate
Nazi Ethics Debate
"In the interest of...saving lives, is
it acceptable to make use of data collected through mutilation, torture,
and death" (Campbell, 16)? That is the question which has been rearing
its head in scientific research since the end of World War II. As man has
sought to quench his thirst for knowledge, lines of ethicality have been
drawn to preserve the integrity of science, and provide a framework from
which man can improve upon the quality of human life. In Nazi concentration
and death camps, the gruesome sibling of science matured. Nazi scientists,
physicians, and scholars tore down the ethical framework of science in
order to eliminate the genetically inferior, and ultimately, attempt to
forge a ‘pure’ race of ‘super-humans’. Members of the Nazi scientific community
were to serve as "alert biological soldiers" (Crum, 33). These ‘soldiers’
conducted research on non-consenting camp inmates in order to "demonstrate
a hereditary basis for group differences in behavioral and physical characteristics"
in humans (Caplan, 286). The most well known experiments in this regard
were the experiments conducted on twins at Auschwitz.
The other goal of the Nazi scientists was
to provide human data that could be applied to the war effort. Experimentation
of this sort mainly probed the extremes, which the human body could tolerate
in a hostile environment. The most famous experiment of this sort was the
‘Dachau Hypothermia Study.’ The rationale of the experiments was
"A consequence of air combat and
air campaigns was that pilots were shot down and landed in cold water.
In addition, the German Navy was losing a large number of personnel in
the cold North Sea. There were no data available to document how long the
downed pilots could survive in the frigid North Sea. The solution to these
questions, as well as others, was considered important by certain groups
of Nazi administrators and scientists. From a historical point of view,
at that time, the number of papers that had been published that dealt with
human response to cold water and/or air was very limited...therefore, the
German scientists were seeking answers to "legitimate scientific goals"
The last line, "...German scientists were
seeking answers to ‘legitimate scientific goals’", is the statement which
is the prime concern of this paper.
In order to accomplish their ‘goals,’ Nazi
scientists conducted human experiments, virtually all of which, ended in
the subjects’ murder. How can answers to ‘legitimate scientific goals’
be found in murder? Should these experiments even be considered ‘science’?
Furthermore, should these experiments be allowed to provide quotable data
to the modern scientific community?
The debate on whether or not science should
allow referencing to Nazi data rages. Objectors to using Nazi data, state
that by using the data from the Nazis’ human experimentation, researchers
are not only endorsing, but also encouraging future unethical research.
In addition, objectors maintain that the Nazi research was poorly designed
and conducted so haphazardly, that it really doesn’t even qualify as ‘scientific’.
They state, "scientific results depended upon protocols which were soaked
in iniquity. In many experiments, it was ‘control subjects’, denied treatment,
who suffered most and died. ‘Sample size’ meant truck loads of Jews. ‘Significance’
was an indication of misery, and ‘response rate’ a measure of torment"
Objectors to the use of Nazi research believe
that nothing good will come from this research. They believe that using
research gathered through murder endorses the methods used in the experiments.
If this statement were to be contested, they would argue that to cite research
is to say ‘I believe in this work’. To believe in research, one must be
inclined to repeat the original work and further investigate the topic.
Objectors claim that this condition is never satisfied. They state, "We
do not, to be specific, replicate the Nazi experiments. ‘We’ do not do
it. The Nazis did" (Campbell, 18). Objectors believe that a scientist above
all else is a human, thus, he must recognize himself as a moral being.
Since humans were murdered in these experiments, the data collected should
be considered ‘tainted’. No moral being should associate with tainted data.
Objectors also believe that the methodology
of these experiments cannot be considered ‘science’. In regard to the infamous
hypothermia experiments at Dachau, United States Brigadier General Telford
Taylor, claimed that, "these experiments revealed nothing which civilized
medicine can use" (Moe, 5). Further opinions from objectors dissect the
reliability of the research. Arnold Relman, editor of the New England Journal
of Medicine, states that Nazi experiments "are such a gross violation of
human standards that they are not to be trusted at all...how can you trust
a man who would do that?" (Moe, 6). Therefore, obviously the Nazi data
Topics Related to Nazi Ethics Debate
Medical ethics, Experiments, Research ethics, Applied ethics, Knowledge, Research, Clinical research, Design of experiments, Nazi human experimentation, Human subject research, Conscientious objector, Scientific method
Essays Related to Nazi Ethics Debate
Beatlemania in the 1960sBeatlemania in the 1960s The Beatles were a mystical happening that many people still don\'t understand. Phenomenoligists had a ball in 1964 with Beatlemania, a generally harmless form of madness which came from Britain in 1963. The sole cause of Beatlemania is a quartet of young Englishmen known as the Beatles. In the less than one year that they achieved popularity in England to the time they came to America, The Beatles achieved a popularity and following that is unprecedented in the history
Nazi Ethics DebateNazi Ethics Debate Nazi Ethics Debate In the interest of...saving lives, is it acceptable to make use of data collected through mutilation, torture, and death (Campbell, 16)? That is the question which has been rearing its head in scientific research since the end of World War II. As man has sought to quench his thirst for knowledge, lines of ethicality have been drawn to preserve the integrity of science, and provide a framework from which man can improve upon the quality of human life. In Na
The Ethics of World DominationThe Ethics of World Domination The Ethics of World Domination Throughout the past 70 years the U.S. has been involved in hundreds of conflicts all around the globe. Every time the United States troops are deployed to a foreign country, citizens of the U.S. want to know why. People begin to ask questions like, what is the purpose of this? or what is the nature of our involvement? Nobody wants to see the strong youth of our nation shipped of to a foreign country to get slaughtered without good
During the past quarter century, abortion has joinDuring the past quarter century, abortion has joined race and war as one of the most debatable subject of controversy in the United States. It discusses human interaction where ethics, emotions and law come together. Abortion poses a moral, social and medical dilemma that faces many individuals to create a emotional and violent atmosphere. There are many points of view toward abortion but the only two fine distinctions are pro-choice and pro-life. A pro-choicer would feel that the decision t
During the past quarter century, abortion has joinDuring the past quarter century, abortion has joined race and war as one of the most debatable subjects of controversy in the United States. It discusses human interaction where ethics, emotions and law are combined. Abortion poses a moral, social and medical dilemmas that focus many individuals to create an emotional and violent atmosphere. There are many points of view toward abortion but the only two fine distinctions are pro-choice and pro-life. A pro-choice person would feel that the de
Over the past fifteen years a powerfully charged dOver the past fifteen years a powerfully charged drama has unfolded in New York\'s Broadway venues and spread to the opera houses and ballet productions of major cities across the country. Its characters include angry college students, aging rock stars, flamboyant B-movie queens, society matrons, and sophisticated fashion designers. You can\'t buy tickets for this production, but you might catch a glimpse of it while driving in Bethesda on particular Saturday afternoons. If you\'re lucky, Compas
Bioethics, which is the study of value judgments pBioethics, which is the study of value judgments pertaining to human conduct in the area of biology and includes those related to the practice of medicine, has been an important aspect of all areas in the scientific field (Bernstein, Maurice, M.D.). It is one of the factors that says whether or not certain scientific research can go on, and if it can, under which rules and regulations it must abide by. One of the most recent and controversial issues facing our society today is the idea of clonin
AbortionAbortion Abortion During the past quarter century, abortion has joined race and war as one of the most debatable subject of controversy in the United States. It discusses human interaction where ethics, emotions and law come together. Abortion poses a moral, social and medical dilemma that faces many individuals to create a emotional and violent atmosphere. There are many points of view toward abortion but the only two fine distinctions are pro-choice and pro-life. A pro-choicer would feel t
Active Euthenasia - A Kantian PerspectiveActive Euthenasia - A Kantian Perspective Matchmaker.com: Sign up now for a free trial. Date Smarter! Active Euthenasia - A Kantian Perspective Euthanasia is one of society\'s more widely, and hotly debated moral issues of our time. More directly, active euthanasia, which by definition, is; Doing something, such as administering a lethal drug, or using other means that cause a person\'s death.1 Passive euthanasia, defined as; Stopping (or not starting) some treatment, which allows a person to
EuthanasiaEuthanasia Let American Consumer Counseling Help you Get Out of Debt! Euthanasia In recent years, Euthanasia has become a very heated debate. It is a Greek word that means easy death but the controversy surrounding it is just the opposite. Whether the issue is refusing prolonged life mechanically, assisting suicide, or active euthanasia, we eventually confront our socity\'s fears toward death itself. Above others, our culture breeds fear and dread of aging and dying. It is not easy for most of
Abortion must be a legal and attainable procedureAbortion must be a legal and attainable procedure for women throughout the United States. Abortion is a subject which easily fits into the themes of CORE 1. Abortion pertains to many issues which are involved in CORE 1. CORE 1 analyzes civil rights as well as equal treatment for women in America. Abortion challenges the civil rights of the mother and the fetus which she bears. To deny abortion is denying the mother certain civil rights, but if the fetus is considered a person, then the rights of
Information TechnologyInformation Technology Information Technology Information technology is a rapidly growing part of today\'s society. It affects everyone\'s life in many aspects. Every human endeavor is influenced by information technology and the increasing rate at which what it can perform includes. One area of human endeavor that information technology has greatly influenced is the practice of medicine, specifically veterinary medicine. Not only has veterinary medicine been influenced by information technology
The New InternetThe New Internet The New Internet Without a doubt, the Internet is undergoing a major transition as it experiences a tremendous influx of new users. Due to the anarchic, distributed nature of the net, we cannot even begin to enumerate the population of the Internet or its growth. As more of the world\'s population moves on-line, new concerns will arise which did not confront the earlier generations. The new culture will demand different resources, services and technology than the old generations